Turnouts which to buy?


3

35tac

Wayne B
I am perfectly happy to date with Atlas code 83 Custom Line NS turnouts. However there is another world out there. PECO, Walthers/Shinohara etc. If I were to need something not available from Atlas which would be the most compatable? Lets be technical and not just plain slam.
Thanks
Wayne
 
I only have experience with atlas customline turnouts and handlaid stuff...However my dad has used a mix of atlas and walthers/shinohara turnouts on his layout and hasn't had any issues with the mix..From people that I have spoken with in the past regarding peco turnouts they absolutely swear by them...The only thing that held me back from peco vs atlas was the price difference I encountered.
 
Technically, it's all HO so you won't have any compatibility issues.

I prefer Peco turnouts because they're built solidly. Shinohara turnouts are a hit or miss.
 
I have had more electrical reliability problems with the Shinohara turnouts as well. I have had better performance with Atlas Code 83 and Walthers Code 83 turnouts.
 
My W/S turnouts need the most fiddling to get them to work without shorting during the passage of conventional HO scale metal tires. Also, for a while at least, say in 2005/6, the inner curved routes on their curved turnouts in Code 83 were considerably shorter in radius than claimed. GGRRRRRRRRRrrrr...!!! :mad:

My Pecos have been very robust and reliable. I could pass on their blade-like points rails, but I guess nothing is perfect. I mean the Streamline Code 83 #6 turnouts with which I am familiar, and of which I have perhaps 20.
 
I love my Peco turnouts. The fact that they 'lock' into place allows me to switch them manually without any additional hardware. Beware that the rail profile is a little different than atlas so the regular joiners take some monkeying around to join. I use all Peco code 83 track and turnouts so I didn't have that problem though.
 
35tac said:
I am perfectly happy to date with Atlas code 83 Custom Line NS turnouts. However there is another world out there. PECO, Walthers/Shinohara etc. If I were to need something not available from Atlas which would be the most compatable? Lets be technical and not just plain slam.
Thanks
Wayne
Click to expand...

I recently bought 12 walthers/sinohara code 83 #6 turnouts for my layout. I wouldn't recommend them, as I was very dissapointed with the quality. I had to add a pin to keep the point rails from flexing outward when a car travelled over causing them to go out of gauge.

They also seemed very flimsy and the tie castings were poor, some ties were just smooth shiny plastic.

I bought a wack of flex track and was also dissapointed with it as each piece had about 25 sprues left on it and had to be nipped off.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.



Back
Top